"I don’t like most people’s style, so if the general public doesn’t like my ring, I know I did something right," newly engaged Abby Bucco tells PEOPLE Ashlyn Robinette is a Weddings Writer at PEOPLE.

When the perfect romantic moment finally comes and the guy drops to one knee, any girl, assuming she loves him back, is excited to see the ring and slip it on. But what if it’s not the ring you ...